View All Horse Shoe NC Oversized Lot Homes Listings

45 Watagnee  Trail, Horse Shoe
$935,000
4405494 MLS
Generational mountain estate property available for the first time publicly consisting of 35 +/- recreational acres primed for use as multi-family estate, working farm, group camp grounds, tiny home community, or short term rental complex for multiple homes. Three parcels make up the total acreage offering, the southwest corner joining Pisgah National Forest boundary, property access by recorded easement road from end of pavement on Watagnee Trail, fresh gravel placed in May 2026. Since being operated as the historic Lion Tamer Hunting Lodge of Mills River, property was used privately as recreational land by current owners and their guests, hosting scouting groups, hunting excursions and weekend stays. Headwater streams daylight at least three locations on property. Original 800 square foot brick cabin sits near entry at top of three acre open field, with open quad bunks, full bathroom, full kitchen, functional wood burning fireplace and all electric power service, well and septic, winterized annually during colder months. Opposite the main cabin, an expansive open air barn keeps equipment weather-safe, and boasts a kitchenette room and an enclosed storage room. Smaller wood and tractor barns line the upper road leading to the studio cabin, a 256 square foot tiny house with 100 foot loft built in 2024, with full bathroom and raised sleeping loft. Wood trim crafted from aged yellow raw pine, custom made book cases and loft ladder, soapstone fully vented propane stove with thermostatic control. Home was designed with the thought it could be relocated to another area of the property, or could serve as a template for multiple tiny homes along the adjacent upper loop road. Upper field boasts 3 cleared acres of gentle hillside ideal for additional residences, structures or new pen or barn construction. Property entrance just 12 minute drive from Mills River, 19 minute drive from Asheville Regional Airport, 24 minutes to Downtown Hendersonville, and 34 minutes to Downtown Asheville. Property not visible from road, drive-bys not possible. Showings available by appointment only.

45 Watagnee Trail, Horse Shoe

23 Benton Farms  Lane, Horse Shoe
$1,999,999
5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 4381023 MLS
Now offered at $1,999,999 following a significant $200,000 price reduction, this exceptional custom estate is being presented at a newly established firm price for a limited time. Built by DMH Builders and recipient of a Gold Craftsmanship Award in the 2024 WNC Parade of Homes, the property offers a rare combination of award-winning craftsmanship, usable acreage, resort-style amenities and a separate ADA-compliant guest house with its full kitchen, private driveway and separate address—ideal for extended family, guests or added flexibility. Unlike many luxury homes tucked into dense subdivisions, this estate offers room to breathe with beautifully landscaped grounds, generous outdoor living spaces, privacy between neighbors and space to garden, play or simply enjoy the mountain setting. A saltwater pool, heated and cooled gym with sauna, greenhouse and detached office/design studio further elevate the property, all without the high HOA fees and restrictive rules often found in comparable communities. Designed for effortless entertaining, the open floor plan showcases soaring ceilings, dramatic rough-sawn beams, a floor-to-ceiling limestone fireplace and oversized sliding doors connecting seamlessly to expansive covered outdoor living with a gas fireplace, mounted TV and poolside gathering spaces. The chef's kitchen features premium ZLINE Autograph Edition appliances, a custom limestone hood, oversized island, granite countertops, bespoke cabinetry and spacious walk-in butler's pantry, while the luxurious main-level primary suite offers a spa-inspired bath with oversized walk-in shower, soaking tub, Taj Mahal quartzite countertops and an extraordinary custom closet. Ideally in desirable West Henderson County, enjoy the peaceful Mills River/Horse Shoe setting just minutes from downtown Hendersonville, the Ecusta Trail, breweries, wineries, shopping and dining, with Asheville and Brevard within an easy 25-30 minute drive. Offered fully furnished, this one-of-a-kind estate delivers the space, privacy, versatility and quality today's luxury buyers are struggling to find, at a strategically repositioned, firm price available for a limited time.

23 Benton Farms Lane, Horse Shoe

Start Your Search

“The data relating to real estate on this website derive in part from the Internet Data Exchange program. Brokers make an effort to deliver accurate information, but buyers should independently verify any information on which they will rely in a transaction. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither Real Estate Company nor any listing broker shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, or misprints, and they shall be held totally harmless from any damages arising from reliance upon this data. This data is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties they may be interested in purchasing. © 2026 Carolina Multiple Listing Services, Inc.”

Horse Shoe, NC · Curated MLS Search

Oversized Lot Homes in Horse Shoe, NC

An editorially curated view of every active oversized lot homes listing in Horse Shoe, NC. Updated in real time from the local MLS, presented without the noise.

Browse Active Listings

Horse Shoe Market — Oversized Lot Homes Comparison

Live MLS data — citywide vs. Oversized Lot Homes

Horse Shoe
Oversized Lot Homes
inventory
Active Listings
58
2
Sold (Past 6 Mo.)
17
0
Under Contract
5
1
pricing
Avg. List Price
$634,698
$1,081,500
Cost / Sq. Ft.
$344
$616
typical home
Living Area
2,729 ft²
3,246 ft²
Avg. Beds
3.3
5.0
Avg. Baths
3.3
6.0
Days on Market
131
118

Oversized Lot Homes in Horse Shoe: Market Data

Data as of (MLS snapshot; listings below update live)

As of October 23, 2026, Jon Tharp Homes' review of MLS data shows 2 active listings for Horse Shoe oversized lot homes. Listings like these do not come up often in Horse Shoe. That is about 3% of the 58 active listings in Horse Shoe across every property type. In addition, 1 listing was under contract at the time. In a market this small, a listing alert is the most reliable way to hear about the next one.

Oversized Lot Homes in Horse Shoe, NC, October 23, 2026
MeasureValue
Active listings2
All active listings in Horse Shoe, every property type58
Under contract1

Oversized Lot Homes in other cities

Market questions

How many Horse Shoe oversized lot homes are on the market?

There were 2 Horse Shoe oversized lot homes for sale as of October 23, 2026, based on Jon Tharp Homes' review of MLS data.

How do Horse Shoe oversized lot homes compare with other cities?

As of October 23, 2026, there were 2 Horse Shoe oversized lot homes for sale. In the same search, Buncombe County had 290 oversized lot homes for sale at a median list price of $596,750, Asheville had 157 oversized lot homes for sale at a median list price of $604,900 and Henderson County had 143 oversized lot homes for sale at a median list price of $449,000.

How many Horse Shoe oversized lot homes are pending?

As of October 23, 2026, 1 listing for Horse Shoe oversized lot homes was under contract.

How do Horse Shoe oversized lot homes compare with all active listings in Horse Shoe?

As of October 23, 2026, there were 2 Horse Shoe oversized lot homes for sale, out of 58 active listings in Horse Shoe across every property type.

Listing data courtesy of Carolina Multiple Listing Services, Inc.

Next Steps in Horse Shoe, NC